FAQ

What is treaty?

The treaty process provides a framework for We Wai Kai, Canada, and BC to work towards a common goal of reconciliation, and building a new relationship through constitutionally protected understandings.

How far are we into the treaty process?

We are in stage 4 of 6 stages, of the treaty process, "Negotiating an Agreement in Principle."

What is being negotiated?

We are currently negotiating jurisdiction of lands, waters, and resources, as well as a land and cash settlement. More information on what we are negotiating specifically can be found in our Agreement in Principle (AIP) Brochure. If you don’t have one yet, contact Jamie Bryant at jbryant@lkts.ca or 250.895.0043.

How many bands are in the BC treaty negotiation process?

65 First Nations, representing 105 current and former Indian Act Bands out of all 200 Indian Act Bands in BC, are participating in, or have completed treaties through the treaty negotiations process. This is 52.5% of all BC Indian Act Bands. Four treaties, representing eight First Nations have been signed in the BCTC treaty process (Maa-nulth, Tla’amin, Tsawwassen and Yale).

Why is it costing so much money just to get a treaty?

Treaty is an important decision for We Wai Kai. We need good, sound advice, tough negotiators and good political resolve as we hold Canada and British Columbia accountable. Treaty negotiations are very complex – we are negotiating a return to self-government for We Wai Kai, and the relationship of the We Wai Kai government with the other governments. It takes a long time to make sure we are positioning We Wai Kai for success. This is for our future generations and we need to ensure it is done right.

How do we ensure we have enough money to sustain ourselves after treaty?

After treaty We Wai Kai will continue to have access to all INAC programing that is available for other non-treaty Nations and it will continue to cover health and education costs. We will also negotiate funding agreements with Canada that will support our governance system. This allows us the opportunity to enhance and build any programs as we see fit using the additional funds we generate from our lands. Our funding levels will remain at least as they are currently, and in most cases will increase.

But nobody wants treaty. Why are we still in it?

This statement is based on unconfirmed and un-surveyed information.  Once we have a negotiated offer from the Federal and Provincial governments, we will have a vote which will allow our citizens to decide whether they want to move forward or not.

How does the voting process on the Agreement in Principle work?

We will hold a community vote. If the majority of our citizens vote yes, we will move forward, if the majority of our citizens vote no, we will not move forward on the Agreement in Principle.

What is self-government?

First Nations were self-governing long before Europeans arrived in Canada. In 1876, the Indian Act dismantled traditional governance systems and imposed strict regulations on Indigenous peoples' lives. Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982, recognizes that Indigenous Peoples have an inherent, constitutionally-protected right to self-government – a right to manage our own affairs. 

Are there other options for self-government besides treaty?

There are no real options for self-government other than treaty, in British Columbia. There are some small measures we can take under various pieces of legislation, including the Land Management Act or  the First Nations Financial Management Act. We can also develop our own Citizenship Code and Election Code under the Indian Act. But these are all half measures and amount to authority delegated or allowed through the Indian Act. The only way to be truly self-governing is through treaty negotiations and economic development.

Define what our aboriginal rights and title are now, and what it will mean after treaty.

Aboriginal rights are essentially the right to hunt, fish, trap and gather for food, social and ceremonial purposes. Aboriginal title is ownership of lands we can show we have occupied "exclusively" for a very long time. Exclusive ownership is difficult to prove, particularly because of overlaps. These rights become expanded under treaty. Under treaty, we get full ownership of the Treaty Settlement Lands and Self-government. We Wai Kai rights and title will not be extinguished through treaty – they will be asserted and exercised in accordance with the treaty.

If the government(s) have not embraced and honoured treaty for other nations who currently have treaty in place, then why does We Wai Kai think that we will fare any better?

All three governments, We Wai Kai, Federal, and Provincial, have a vested interest in ensuring the success of our treaty, therefore, the treaty commitment needs to be clear, fair and implemented within the spirit and interest of treaty. There will also be a review period and a dispute resolution chapter. If governments do not honour the treaties, the treaties provide the legal remedies.

What is bad about our system now?

Under the current system we do not own our lands. We are "allowed" to live on Indian Reserves, at Canada’s discretion, in the way Canada requires. We do not make our own laws, and are always subject to the whim of the Minister of Indian Affairs. We are the only people in Canada, other than those in prison, to live so completely under the control of an executive branch of government (Satsan from Frances Abele, Like an ill-fitting boot: Government, governance and management systems in the contemporary Indian Act (p.32))

Because we do not own our lands we have limited opportunities for economic development. This has made many Indian Reserves lands of poverty and abuse surrounded by other lands of wealth.

It is under the Indian Act that the residential school system was carried out. It all happened under the Indian Act and under the "protection" of the Minister of Indian Affairs. The potlatch system was also banned and our language was forbidden under the Indian Act.

Simply because it is something we are used to and know does not mean we should continue to accept living under its weight and control.

Do we lose our status and healthcare if we sign a treaty? If not, what happens with health?

We will continue to be eligible for all programs and services (including health care, social services and education) available to Aboriginal people and we will continue to be "Status Indians" for these purposes. We Wai Kai has the opportunity to enhance health and education by developing programs for these important services.

Is the post- treaty government run by elected representatives?

Yes. The structure of treaty government will be developed based on the Constitution that We Wai Kai people build. We will vote on our Constitution and it will form the bases of our government and laws. After treaty, the band will no longer exist. There will be a transition period during which the Chief and Council will form the government.  After the transition period, the new government will be elected based on the Constitution. 

What can we do to ensure that our treaty government will be held accountable?

Accountability requires the participation of citizens. Citizens have an obligation to inform themselves and to question their government. In the draft Constitution being developed there will be requirements for laws and policies in place to ensure the We Wai Kai Government is held accountable, but this will only happen if you exercise your rights as citizens.

What stops our "newfound" government from becoming corrupt?

The best tool to prevent government corruption is to have informed and active citizens. Treaty will also provide tools of good government. There will be laws and policies in place to prevent this from happening. There will be an impartial and independent process for We Wai Kai citizens and other individuals who live on We Wai Kai lands to appeal or ask for a review of We Wai Kai government decisions. Currently, under the Indian Act, there is no formal process to review or challenge decisions made by the We Wai Kai Chief and Council, other than in the courts.

Will there be laws and policies in place?

Yes, there will be laws and policies in place. These will be developed by We Wai Kai for We Wai Kai. Our Constitution will define how our laws are passed.

Post-treaty, how can We Wai Kai make revenue?

For economic opportunities, We Wai Kai will have treaty settlement lands it can develop. We Wai Kai will also have better forestry opportunities through treaty and we will receive a significant amount of the revenue from all GST and PST transactions on our lands. We will also have greater opportunities to create Joint Venture partnerships and create greater opportunities for our citizens.

Why will we have to pay taxes after treaty?

Currently our tax exemption is limited and is only based on language in the Indian Act. It is not an Aboriginal right. Indian Affairs is working to remove tax exemption opportunities and it’s anticipated that in the future very few, if any people will be eligible. Treaty gives us the opportunity to ensure that the taxes our citizens pay are returned to us, an option we don’t have once the exemption is lost outside of treaty.

Who is going to be accountable for our money and funding?

Currently, our We Wai Kai Administration is accountable for our money received from Indian Affairs. This will not change, but post-treaty our We Wai Kai Government will be accountable to our citizens under our Constitution. It will not be accountable to the Minister or Indian Affairs. Our citizens, through our Constitution and governance will ensure that laws and policies are in place to ensure accountability and transparent financial management of all We Wai Kai money and funding.

How do we manage our finances? How do we ensure the people are properly trained if they are not schooled?

We do and will continue to manage our finances in a manner that conforms to financial management standards applicable to public governments. Individual citizens are provided with opportunities for education and training, but the ultimate responsibility is with the citizens themselves. The We Wai Kai Government can provide opportunities but it is up to each individual citizen to take advantage of the opportunities and use their own initiative. 

What is "fee simple" land compared to Indian Reserves and Treaty Settlement Lands?

Fee simple lands: Federal and Provincial law recognizes this as the highest form of land ownership. The property owner is entitled to full enjoyment of the property, limited only by zoning laws, deed or subdivision restrictions or covenants, all of which are done through Provincial law. The property owner is responsible for paying all taxes established by the government. Fee simple lands can be sold, mortgages inherited.

Indian Reserve lands: The Indian Act (Sec. 18(1)) states that reserves are "held by Her Majesty for the use and benefit of the respective bands for which they were set apart, and subject to this Act and to the terms of any treaty or surrender, the Governor in Council may determine whether any purpose for which lands in a reserve are used or are to be used is for the use and benefit of the band." In other words, Canada owns reserve lands and allows us to use them as long as the Minister agrees with said use.

Treaty Settlement Land: Sometimes called "fee simple plus" because it is ownership plus jurisdiction. We will own our Treaty Settlement lands.  We will have law-making authorities on our Treaty Settlement Lands and we will develop them as we determine. We will no longer be under Canada’s or British Columbia’s authority on our own lands.

Will treaty extinguish Aboriginal title?

One of the key challenges of the treaty process is to achieve certainty of land ownership and jurisdiction, while not extinguishing aboriginal title.  In the past, the Government of Canada required First Nations to "cede, release and surrender" their aboriginal rights in exchange for treaty rights. This is referred to as an "extinguishment model." We are now negotiating an agreement that will not extinguish our title to our lands and will define how we will exercise our rights. We Wai Kai rights and title will not be extinguished through treaty – they will be asserted and exercised in accordance with the treaty.

How much have we borrowed for treaty and do we have to pay it back?

We have been negotiating for just We Wai Kai since April 1, 2014. We Wai Kai’s portion of the treaty debt, as of March 31, 2017 is $4,392,348. An additional $549,682 debt is held by the treaty society for Mamalillikulla who will assume that debt when they re-enter the treaty process. When other Nations left the Treaty Society they each took their share of the debt.

Repayment is usually done based on a repayment schedule once the Final Agreement is implemented. In all of the treaties that have been signed to date, there has been a "sweetener", or capital/infrastructure project (e.g. the Nisga’a Highway) that is roughly the value of the loan, so as to offset the loan. As well, there are ongoing high-level negotiations occurring in an attempt to have all treaty loans forgiven.